Baby’s First Christmas Gift Guide: Memorable Picks

Keepsakes That Capture the Magic

The first Christmas with a baby is a moment suspended in time—a memory you’ll want to revisit for years to come. Keepsakes are more than just objects; they’re time capsules that help families hold onto the fleeting magic of babyhood. We’re drawn to gifts that invite storytelling and reflection, like a keepsake ornament designed for new parents. One of our favorite finds is an ornament that doubles as a mini memory book, allowing parents and siblings to add a handwritten note each year on tiny scrolls. Over time, these little messages become a cherished family tradition, offering a window into the joys, surprises, and even the chaos of those early years [1].

Personalized gifts are another way to make the season unforgettable. A custom baby board book, for example, can feature family photos and simple stories, giving little ones a sense of belonging while becoming a treasured memento for parents [5]. Framed handprint or footprint kits are also popular, capturing the tininess of those first months in a way that’s both tangible and heartwarming. These keepsakes aren’t just for display—they’re invitations to pause, reflect, and celebrate how much your family has grown.

We also love the idea of a memory journal or a “first five years” book, which encourages parents to jot down milestones, funny moments, and holiday highlights. Years from now, flipping through these pages will bring back the sights, sounds, and feelings of your baby’s first Christmas. The best keepsakes are the ones that spark conversation and connection, whether you’re reminiscing over cocoa or sharing stories with future generations.

Cozy and Festive Holiday Wear

There’s something undeniably sweet about dressing your baby in holiday pajamas or a festive romper for their first Christmas morning. For many families, a new pair of pajamas is a beloved tradition—one that makes those early-morning photos even more adorable. We gravitate toward styles that are both fun and practical, like soft cotton footed pajamas in classic plaids or whimsical prints (think robots, yetis, or even subtle nods to favorite fandoms) [3]. The best holiday wear is comfortable enough for sleep, sturdy enough for play, and cute enough for every photo op.

If you’re looking for something that stands out from the usual elf costumes, there are plenty of contemporary options that celebrate the season without veering into kitsch. Minimalist rompers in wintery hues, matching family pajama sets, or even a cozy sweater with a subtle holiday motif can all make for memorable gifts. We especially appreciate pieces that are well-made and can be passed down to siblings or saved as a keepsake for years to come.

Don’t overlook the practical side of festive wear, either. Babies spend a lot of time napping, crawling, and exploring, so look for soft, breathable fabrics and easy-to-change designs. A well-chosen holiday outfit can become part of your family’s seasonal rituals, whether it’s worn for Christmas Eve stories, morning gift-opening, or that all-important first visit to see the lights.

Playful Gifts That Grow With Baby

The best baby gifts are the ones that invite curiosity, encourage exploration, and adapt as your child grows. For a first Christmas, we recommend open-ended toys that foster creativity and development. Wooden stacking sets, for example, are timeless favorites that help babies practice fine motor skills, color recognition, and problem-solving. As little ones grow, these same toys can be used in new ways, supporting imaginative play well into toddlerhood [2].

Shape sorters and sensory toys are also excellent choices. Look for options with different textures, colors, and sounds to engage your baby’s senses and support early learning. We’re especially fond of toys made from safe, durable materials—think food-grade silicone or sustainably sourced wood—that can withstand years of enthusiastic play. A well-designed shape sorter, for instance, introduces basic concepts like cause and effect while doubling as a teething-friendly companion [2].

Musical instruments, such as a solid drum or a set of soft rattles, are another way to spark joy and discovery. Babies love to experiment with sound, and instruments designed for little hands can help develop rhythm, coordination, and a lifelong love of music. For families who value STEM learning, consider a simple activity gym or a play kit that introduces early science concepts through play [5]. These gifts aren’t just fun—they’re building blocks for a curious, confident learner.

Books are another gift that grows with your child. Board books with high-contrast images, interactive flaps, or even basic sign language can become bedtime favorites and support language development from the very start [2]. Personalized storybooks add an extra layer of magic, making your baby the star of their own holiday adventure.

Thoughtful Essentials for Everyday Moments

Not every memorable gift needs to be a keepsake or a toy—sometimes, the most appreciated presents are the ones that make daily life a little smoother. Thoughtful essentials like a nightlight and sound machine can help establish soothing bedtime routines, making those first months a bit more restful for everyone [5]. We’re big fans of products that combine function with a touch of delight, such as a nightlight that doubles as a gentle music player or a sound machine with customizable settings.

Practical baby care kits are another smart choice. A well-stocked set might include a nasal aspirator, nail clippers, and other essentials that new parents will reach for again and again [5]. These gifts may not be flashy, but they’re invaluable during those long nights and busy mornings. Feeding sets, wearable blankets, and soft bathrobes also fall into this category—items that blend comfort, safety, and everyday usefulness.

For families who love to read, a personalized baby book or a “first five years” memory journal can turn ordinary moments into lasting memories. These gifts encourage parents to document milestones, jot down favorite stories, and reflect on the small joys that make each day special [5]. Even a simple, beautifully designed board book can become a treasured part of your family’s daily routine.

We also appreciate gifts that support sensory exploration and self-soothing, like a plush lovey or a silicone teether. These items offer comfort and familiarity, helping babies navigate new experiences with confidence. The best essentials are the ones that blend seamlessly into family life, offering both practicality and a sense of celebration.

As you celebrate your baby’s first Christmas, remember that the most meaningful gifts are those that spark connection, inspire curiosity, and create memories you’ll cherish for years to come. Whether you choose a keepsake ornament, a cozy pair of pajamas, a playful learning toy, or a thoughtful essential, your gift will become part of your family’s unique holiday story. Wishing you a season filled with wonder, warmth, and joyful discoveries.

Sources

[1] This Christmas ornament for new parents preserves memories so … — https://coolmompicks.com/blog/2017/12/17/baby-memories-keepsake-ornament/

[2] The 35 Best Gifts for 1-Year-Olds for 2025 | Reviews by Wirecutter — https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/gifts/best-gifts-toys-for-1-year-olds/

[3] 5 cool Christmas pajamas for babies that won’t make them look like … — https://coolmompicks.com/blog/2017/12/17/christmas-pajamas-for-babies-no-elves/

[4] Best Gifts for Kids: Holiday Gift Ideas for Kids | Wirecutter — https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/gifts/kids/

[5] The 75 Best Baby Gifts of 2025: Thoughtful Ideas Parents Love — https://www.parents.com/best-baby-gifts-8607477